In this analysis, we assess a new plan to restructure the GSEs sure not only to be considered by the Obama Treasury if it issues the promised RFI on a “utility” approach, but also and far more importantly in any Democratic Administration to come. We confess up-front to a lack of objectivity about this proposal – it favors a government corporation akin to one we have outlined in prior reports not only for the GSEs, but also FHA and agree that its transitional approach may ease the nation into a privatized GSE-style utility without the shock of the new one that has stymied most other plans. One challenge we foresee – rightly raised in the report as a worry – is the procyclicality of the new structure. This protects taxpayers, but undermines the entity’s market liquidity function. We doubt a counter-cyclical capital buffer will cure for this because we’ve yet to see a proposal for one that works, but a counter-cyclical fee structure could solve for this systemic worry if correctly structured and acceptable to the market.

The full report is available to subscription clients. To find out how you can sign up for the service, click here.